All Bagel Recipes

Every bagel recipe on Benefitiany is a piece of my story — born from a love of wholesome ingredients and the cozy memories of baking with my grandmother. What started as an experiment with Greek yogurt and cottage cheese quickly became a passion for creating protein-rich bagels that are simple, satisfying, and made with care. Whether you’re craving a two-ingredient classic, a savory twist, or a breakfast bagel that fuels your day, you’ll find it here. These aren’t just bagels — they’re moments of comfort, made healthier for real life. Let’s bake something better, one protein-packed bite at a time.

The Ultimate Onion Bagels Recipe

The Ultimate Onion Bagels Recipe

How to make homemade onion bagels with crispy outsides and chewy insides. Simple ingredients, foolproof recipe!

Easy Homemade Egg Bagels

Easy Homemade Egg Bagels

Homemade egg bagels, golden and chewy with that classic shine—perfect for cozy weekend breakfasts that feel straight from a New York bakery.

Bagel and Cottage Cheese Treats in 30 Minutes

Bagel and Cottage Cheese Treats in 30 Minutes

Fluffy, golden bagel and cottage cheese treats packed with protein—ready in 30 minutes, perfect for busy mornings and lazy weekend brunches alike.

Sweet Cottage Cheese Bagels with Cinnamon and Raisins

Sweet Cottage Cheese Bagels with Cinnamon and Raisins

These cinnamon raisin bagels are soft, golden, and packed with cinnamon-sugar flavor—ready in 40 minutes for a cozy morning treat you’ll crave again.

Perfect Overnight NY Style Bagels at Home

Perfect Overnight NY Style Bagels at Home

These hand-rolled overnight NY style bagels bring that bakery magic home—chewy, glossy, and full of that unmistakable New York flavor.

Low Carb Bagels Ready in Just 42 Minutes

Low Carb Bagels Ready in Just 42 Minutes

These low carb bagels came from a rainy-day kitchen challenge—and turned into our family’s favorite weekend breakfast with only 4 net carbs each.

Whole Wheat Bagels – Chewy, Golden, Oil-Free

Whole Wheat Bagels – Chewy, Golden, Oil-Free

Homemade whole wheat bagels with a chewy crust and nutty flavor—this oil-free recipe is weekend comfort food that’s wholesome, easy, and deeply satisfying.

Fresh Baked Bagels at Home – Chewy & Golden

Fresh Baked Bagels at Home – Chewy & Golden

Bring the magic of a New York bakery to your kitchen with these fresh baked bagels—golden, chewy, customizable, and tested for perfect weekend mornings.

Next

After testing hundreds of bagel variations in our kitchen, we’ve perfected the art of high protein bagel recipes that actually work. Our collection features tried-and-tested protein bagel recipes that have been made thousands of times by home bakers who refuse to settle for bland, cardboard-like “healthy” alternatives.

Every Greek yogurt bagel recipe and cottage cheese bagel variation has been optimized for both nutrition and flavor, ensuring you get maximum protein (12-20g per bagel) without sacrificing the chewy, satisfying texture that makes bagels a breakfast favorite. These healthy bagel recipes use real ingredients, require minimal equipment, and deliver consistent results that rival your favorite bakery.