The Ultimate New York Style Bagels

🧡 I still remember my first bite of a real New York Style bagels – that perfect contrast between the crackly crust and chewy inside made my heart sing! These homemade New York style bagels bring that same magic right to your kitchen. Trust me, the extra step of making a sponge might seem fussy, but it’s actually the secret to that authentic flavor we all crave!

It all started in my Grandma’s kitchen, where baking was never rushed. “Good things take time,” she’d say with a wink while working dough with her flour-dusted hands. When I first tried making New York bagels at home, I’ll admit I was intimidated. The boiling step seemed strange, and what even is diastatic malt powder? But that first batch – watching those puffy rounds transform in the oven into golden, shiny bagels – took me straight back to my favorite deli corner in Manhattan.

What makes New York bagels special isn’t just one thing – it’s the careful dance of technique and patience. The sponge method we’re using here gives the yeast time to develop those complex flavors that make your kitchen smell like a proper bagel shop. And don’t skip the boiling step! That’s what gives these bagels their signature chewy texture and glossy exterior that simply can’t be replicated any other way.

Ready to bring a taste of New York to your breakfast table? Let’s get baking!

Why You’ll Love These Authentic New York Style Bagels

Making bagels from scratch might seem intimidating at first, but I promise the results are worth every minute. Having tested this recipe countless times in my own kitchen, I’ve found that the sponge method truly captures that classic New York deli flavor that’s impossible to find in store-bought versions.

• True New York texture – The perfect balance of a crackling crust with that distinctive chewy interior that makes your jaw work just the right amount
• Made with simple pantry ingredients – Nothing fancy required besides the malt powder (which I’ll show you how to substitute if needed)
• Better than anything from the grocery store – Once you taste these fresh from your oven, those plastic-wrapped versions will never satisfy you again
• Freezer-friendly for busy mornings – Make a batch on the weekend and enjoy authentic bagels whenever the craving strikes
• Completely customizable – From classic sesame to everything bagels, you can create your perfect flavor combination

These bagels connect me to memories of Sunday mornings in my grandmother’s kitchen – the smell of fresh baking, the anticipation of that first warm bite with cream cheese melting into all the nooks and crannies. It’s more than just breakfast; it’s a little moment of joy you can create in your own home.

Ingredient Note List

Bread Flour: I always use bread flour for my New York bagels because its higher protein content creates that characteristic chewy texture we all love.

Active Dry Yeast: This is what brings your bagels to life – I prefer active dry yeast for bagels as it allows for that slow, flavor-developing fermentation.

Sugar: Just a touch wakes up the yeast and adds a subtle sweetness that balances the salty, savory notes in a proper New York-style bagel.

Diastatic Malt Powder: This special ingredient is my secret weapon for that authentic bagel shop flavor and gorgeous brown crust – it contains enzymes that help the yeast ferment more effectively.

Barley Malt Syrup: I add this to both the dough and boiling water for that subtle malty sweetness that’s the hallmark of a genuine New York bagel.

Kosher Salt: I always use kosher salt in my bagels – the larger crystals distribute perfectly through the dough and enhance all the other flavors.

Water: The temperature matters here! I’ve found that getting your water to about 90°F helps activate the yeast just right for the perfect rise.

How to Cook Authentic New York Style Bagels?

Step 1. I always start by preparing the sponge – this pre-ferment is my grandmother’s secret to developing deep flavor. Mix the warm water, sugar, yeast, and bread flour in a large bowl until well combined, then cover and let it work its magic for about 3 hours until bubbly and fragrant.

Step 2. For the dough, I gently mix the remaining bread flour, malt powder, and salt right into the sponge bowl – no need to dirty another dish! My grandmother always said bagel dough should feel stiff and resilient, so don’t worry if it seems dense compared to other bread doughs.

Step 3. I’ve found that kneading bagel dough thoroughly is essential for that authentic texture. Whether using a stand mixer (about 20 minutes on low) or kneading by hand (a good arm workout!), keep going until the dough is smooth, stiff, and passes the windowpane test.

Step 4. My favorite part is shaping these New York-style bagels! After dividing the dough into equal portions, I roll each piece into a tight ball first, then poke my thumb through the center and gently stretch to form that classic ring with about a 2-inch hole.

Step 5. TThe boiling step is non-negotiable for authentic New York bagels! If you’re curious about unique twists, our Sourdough Discard Bagels offer a tangy variation with a chewy bite. I always add barley malt syrup to the water – this gives the bagels their distinctive glossy finish and contributes to that perfect chewy crust that sets New York bagels apart from impostors.

Step 6. When applying toppings, I’ve learned they stick best if added immediately after boiling while the surface is still wet and tacky. For everything bagels, I gently press the seeds into both sides for maximum coverage—similar to how we top our Bagel Recipe with Crunchy Topping like Panera.

Step 7. II bake my New York bagels at a higher temperature than most breads—just like in our soft and chewy Jalapeño Cheddar Bagels for a bold, spicy twist. 425-450°F gives them that perfect golden-brown exterior while keeping the inside pleasantly chewy. The aroma filling your kitchen will transport you straight to a Manhattan bagel shop!

Step 8. My grandmother always said patience is the hardest part of bagel making – letting them cool slightly on a wire rack allows the texture to set properly, though I can rarely resist stealing one while it’s still warm!

The Science Behind Boiling Bagels

The boiling step is what gives New York bagels their distinctive chewy texture and shiny crust — it’s not optional!

What Happens During Boiling:

• Gelatinization: The heat causes starches on the surface to gelatinize, creating that distinctive chewy exterior.
• Crust Formation: Pre-gelatinized starches form a barrier that limits how much the bagels can rise in the oven, keeping them dense inside.
• Shine Development: The alkaline water (from the barley malt or baking soda) helps develop the characteristic shine.

Boiling Time Affects Texture:

• 30 seconds per side: Yields a softer crust with moderate chewiness.
• 1 minute per side: Creates the classic NY bagel texture (recommended).
• 2 minutes per side: Results in an extra chewy, very dense bagel.

Water Additions:

• Barley malt syrup (traditional): Adds color, shine and subtle sweetness.
• Honey (substitute): Lighter color but still creates shine.
• Baking soda (1 tsp): Increases alkalinity, enhancing browning and shine.

How to Store & Reheat

I typically store my freshly baked New York-style bagels in a paper bag for the first day, which helps maintain that delightful crusty exterior. For longer storage (up to 3 days), I transfer them to an airtight container lined with a paper towel to absorb excess moisture.

For the best long-term storage, I slice my bagels before freezing them individually in plastic wrap, then gather them all in a freezer bag. They keep beautifully for up to 3 months this way, and I can easily grab just what I need.

When it comes to reheating, I’ve found that toasting frozen bagels straight from the freezer works surprisingly well! For that fresh-baked taste, though, I prefer thawing them at room temperature for about 30 minutes, then warming in a 350°F oven for 5 minutes. This revives that magical contrast between the crusty exterior and chewy interior that makes New York-style bagels so special.

this …

What to Serve with New York Style Bagels

Classic Cream Cheese Schmear: Nothing beats a thick layer of creamy cream cheese on a fresh bagel – I like to whip mine with a fork first for that perfect spreadable texture that melts slightly into the warm bread.

Lox and All the Fixings: My weekend tradition is serving these bagels with thinly sliced smoked salmon, capers, red onion slices, and a squeeze of lemon – it’s a brunch that makes any day feel special.

Homemade Egg Salad: The rich, creamy texture of egg salad pairs beautifully with the chewy resistance of a New York bagel – I add a touch of dill and capers to mine for extra flavor. It also works wonderfully served with our Protein Packed Cottage Cheese Bagels.

Avocado and Everything Seasoning: For a modern twist that still honors tradition, I love mashing ripe avocado with a squeeze of lemon and a sprinkle of everything bagel seasoning on a toasted bagel. You can also try it on our soft Greek Yogurt Blueberry Bagel Recipe for a sweet-savory combo.

Fresh Fruit Platter: The simplicity of fresh seasonal fruit balances the hearty, satisfying nature of these bagels – especially nice when serving for brunch with friends. Add in a couple of our 2-Ingredient Protein Bagels for a high-protein option guests will love.

FAQs

Print